Mamdani sets out plan to close Rikers Island by 2032

Rikers sits on a 413-acre (167-hectare) island between Queens and the Bronx. More than 6,500 people are held there at a time, and the complex has faced criticism over staffing shortages, deteriorating conditions and inmate deaths, including nine this year. Among those held there while awaiting trial have been Tupac Shakur, DMX and Harvey Weinstein.

The closure timetable has shifted.

New York City’s plans to shut the jail date back to 2019, when the city council first voted for its closure. Legislation later required Rikers to close by 2027, but the effort has been delayed, partly because of difficulties finding places to hold inmates. Mamdani blamed delays under former Mayor Eric Adams’ administration and the Covid pandemic.

Under Adams, a federal judge removed the complex from city control last year and appointed an independent outside official to make decisions about it. Mamdani’s updated schedule still needs approval from the New York City Council. Council members, including the city’s speaker, have indicated support for the proposal.

Mamdani’s plan, detailed in an 88-page report released on Friday, sets out a closure target of 2032. He described Rikers as the result of deteriorating infrastructure and said officials had a moral imperative to close it.

Four jails would replace the island complex.

Mamdani’s office says the city intends to open four facilities on this schedule:

The mayor’s office says the smaller jails would give detainees access to daylight, fresh air and clean space, and that this would lead to better outcomes. It also says the facilities would be easier for families to reach; journeys to Rikers can take hours.

The population target is disputed.

Mamdani wants to bring the number held at Rikers down from more than 6,500 to 4,100. The NYC Correction Officers’ Benevolent Association has challenged that target, saying a cap at that level would put public safety and officers at risk. The union also argues that reaching the figure would require the city to release people charged with violent felonies irresponsibly.

Dana Kaplan, the city’s Close Rikers Czar, has defended the aim of reducing incarceration. She said it was possible for New York City to hold fewer people in jail and that planning should reflect that. Kaplan also described the proposal as a chance to change how detention is handled and to consider more appropriate ways to hold people.

The plan includes alternatives to detention.

Mamdani said his administration would seek to reduce the number of people held in jails across the city. The proposed measures include alternatives to detention for some people awaiting trial, online bail payments for families and efforts to speed up pretrial proceedings. He also wants hundreds of beds in therapeutic housing for prisoners with serious mental health issues.

Kaplan said the administration had already opened 100 therapeutic beds at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan, moving 100 people off Rikers. The proposal also allocates $146m (£111m) to support treatment addressing mental health and substance-use needs, as well as vocational and education programmes inside and outside the jails.

The updated plan therefore pairs a 2032 closure target with four replacement jails and a proposed reduction in the number of people detained.